Schuylkill surged early behind the aggressive play of Omar Jimenez, who led all Schuylkill's scorers with 18 points. York used a deadly accurate three point attack, from Evan Ehrhart to regain control of the game before halftime, 41-39. After the break, the game continued to be back and forth, Schuylkill using strong play off the bench from Romo Morrison, Kenford Lynch and Nate Yost to keep the game tight.
Trailing 76-73 Schuylkill's Patrick Killian was fouled on a three point attempt by Logan Steckel. Killian would make one of three, fouling out on the rebound following the third free throw. Killian's foul sent York's Xavier Smith to the line for one and one, Smith missed the front end and Schuylkill's Jimenez rebounded and outleted the ball to Nurse Jr. who hit freshman, point guard Yost up the right sideline, banking in a three point field goal with 4 seconds remaining. York's Ehrhart would get off an attempt at a game winner from just over mid court that went wide right giving Schuylkill a shocking one point win.